Charmed Life

DIY Halloween Costumes That Don't Involve Party City

The ins and outs of DIY costumes with Milk & Ice Vintage.

By Lauren Bell | October 7, 2016, 11:08 am

Hunter S. Thompson costume. -Photography by Lauren Bell
Charmed Life

DIY Halloween Costumes That Don't Involve Party City

The ins and outs of DIY costumes with Milk & Ice Vintage.

By Lauren Bell | October 7, 2016, 11:08 am

Hunter S. Thompson costume. -Photography by Lauren Bell

If you aren't already following Milk & Ice Vintage on Instagram, now is the time to do so. Not only are the owners always posting dreamy photos of vintage apparel and accessories, but during the month of October, they fill your feed with incredibly creative DIY Halloween costume ideas using all vintage items. We talked to owners Angie Gavin and Kate Thomas about the DIY costumes, what it takes to make them work, and their favorite in-store Halloween memories.

Why did you start creating Halloween costumes on the store's Instagram?
Kate Thomas: We are just very into Halloween. It excites us. I mean we opened the store in September of 2014, but we’ve been together for awhile and we knew immediately when opening the store that we had to do something for Halloween.

Angie Gavin: It’s our favorite time of year.

KT: And combining it with vintage just makes it even more fun.

Do you get a lot of customers asking for your help with their costumes?
AG: Totally. Last year the gal that works at Corner Charcuterie Bar was telling us she really liked our posts and so we asked her to help us because we didn't know what costume to do for Instagram the next day. We just knew we wanted to do a historical figure. She actually informed us of the person who invented bloomers or something, this weird historical figure that we didn’t know about. So it’s been fun to involve our customers in it too.

KT: I remember someone specifically coming in and seeing our posts and looking for a costume for Princess Peach from Super Mario Brothers. We had the perfect pink dress that looked exactly like the character. It was just cool, to be like, 'Actually, I do have that '70s pink outfit that the princess wore in a Nintendo game.'

Dr. Quinn Medicine Woman costume. -Photography by Lauren Bell

Do you think people are intimidated to try a DIY costume?
AG: Sometimes I feel like people just don’t think about it. But that’s what we are here for. We want to walk with you on this journey.

KT: We take people to a different level of costume. It’s not just going to a Halloween store and finding a pre-made "sexy" Raggedy Ann thing. You can come here and get an actual red and white gingham house dress and possibly even wear it again. You can get a cape and be so many different characters, but then you can wear a cape for winter.

There is nothing worse than “sexy _________” costumes.
AG: Yeah, we are so not into that. We find it funny when we are like, 'I’ll be this gross thing.' And maybe that is a confidence thing, but don’t be afraid to be something different. Like if you are a dude and you want to do a tight shave on your head and be Eleven from Stranger Things, you should go for it.

KT: In some cases, you gain confidence after you have everything on. I mean, I was dressed as Doc Brown yesterday from Back to the Future and, as soon as I had it all on I was like, 'Man, I look fucking cool.' And it wasn’t exactly what he looked like, but we made it work with everything that we had.

Wednesday Addams costume. -Photography by Lauren Bell

What is the key piece or item to pull off a DIY costume?
AG: We always say that accessories are really important. If you don’t have the exact outfit or color that the character wears, you can still pull it off with accessories. Like if you are being Jackie Kennedy Onassis, you don’t have to have a '60s pink two-piece suit, you can wear a blue one. But get the pill box hat, gloves, pearls, and all the little things that are nuance-y. Wigs and makeup can help a lot, too. We always tell people for $20 you can do a head-to-toe look in our shop and then spend the rest of your money on a wig and/or makeup from a specialty or Halloween store.

What is your favorite costume you’ve put together in the store?
AG: I think Nancy Kerrigan and Tonya Harding was pretty funny because it really was random. We found these ‘60s leotards and of course we didn’t have ice skates or anything but I think the angle worked.

KT: That one was really fun because it was so random and we were like, "Huh, we have these leotards, what are we going to do?" And then we had to research to characters to make sure Tonya was the one with the baton.

Stepford wives costume. -Photography by Lauren Bell

What are you being for Halloween this year?
AG: After doing this now for three years, we always end up doing something avant-garde and really out there for our personal costumes because we have all month to think about it. If we have funny things that we have ideas about we get that creativity out through the month of October for the store.

KT: Last year we were the sun and the moon, but it was very ’30s style. We had pin curls, gowns, and big headpieces.

I've noticed you guys also do amazing Halloween window displays each year. How do you come up with the theme for the windows?
AG: This year we did Stranger Things, which kind of caters to vintage. We felt like we had to do it. The timing was so perfect.

KT: Our first year we did witches and they were all in crazy vintage black gowns. Last year we did Carrie with a mannequin in a vintage prom dress, and then someone pulling the cord to pour the bucket of blood, which was actually metallic streamers, onto her head.




Meet The Author

Lauren Bell is the style editor for Baltimore, where she covers shopping, fashion, home, and health and wellness.



You May Also Like

Style & Shopping

Signature Scents

How to find the perfume that is subtly and distinctly you.

Charmed Life

Style File: This Sporting Life

Designer Arvay Adams fuses passions for chainstitch and history in his popular sporting goods brand.

Charmed Life

Style File: Found Studio Shop

Get to know Kacey Stafford, owner of Lauraville's Found Studio Shop.


Charmed Life

Five New Year's Eve Style Trends

Wondering what to wear to ring in 2020? We've got you covered.

Health & Wellness

Cold Affront

Winter-proof beauty updates to protect your skin.

Health & Wellness

Making Strides

Accomplish your New Year's fitness resolutions with these eco-friendly products.

Connect With Us

Most Read


Will Judge Make an Example Out of Catherine Pugh?: With the former mayor’s sentencing scheduled for February, both sides get to work on their case.

Maya Rockeymoore Cummings Declares For Late Husband’s Seat: We break down the familiar faces in upcoming special Democratic primary.

Religious Leaders React to Proposed Increase in Funding to Prevent Hate Crimes: Van Hollen, Sarbanes, and Cardin want to quadruple aid protecting local religious groups.

Orioles Execs Not Mentioned in ‘AstroGate’ Sign-Stealing Scandal: GM Mike Elias and the O’s other ex-Astros employees have steered clear of the fallout.

What to Know About the Maryland Cycling Classic Coming September 2020: For starters, Baltimore's pro cycling event will be more than 100 miles long.