Charmed Life

We Tried on Four Holiday Lipsticks So You Don't Have To

Depending on skin tone and hair color, these products aren't one size fit all.

By Michelle Harris | November 8, 2017, 10:38 am

Charmed Life

We Tried on Four Holiday Lipsticks So You Don't Have To

Depending on skin tone and hair color, these products aren't one size fit all.

By Michelle Harris | November 8, 2017, 10:38 am

When the temperatures drop, not only do we unpack our sweaters and boots, but our makeup palette gets a little darker, too. With family feasts, office soirees, and holiday parties filling up our calendar, we wanted to review bold lip colors for the season. Subscription makeup service Birchbox sent us some goodies—all available in the Baltimore locations of Ulta, Sephora, Nordstrom, and Urban Outfitters. 

1. Gnarly by Milk Makeup

Gnarly-Sarah.jpg#asset:50542

Sarah

Gnarly-Molly.jpg#asset:50541

Molly


Gnarly-Lydia.jpg#asset:50539

Lydia

Gnarly-Michelle-2.jpg#asset:53331

Michelle

Sarah: I like the applicator shape, the point gives you more precision. This is a color I would wear—reminds me of an orchid. Looks good with my hair color. I have a lot of pink undertones, so pinks with blue in them look better. Texture is smooth and doesn’t feel like it will go anywhere. Her favorite!

Lydia: It feels dreamy, goes on really nice and smooth. This is definitely too pink for me, but it feels good and I like the applicator. I think it washes me out a little bit, and I don't like the way it makes my skin tone look.

Molly: I like the consistency of it. Feels like you’re not really wearing anything. It’s very pink, but it doesn’t make my face too rosy. I like it. I think it’s a fun color.

Michelle: The applicator shape is awesome, it goes on really smooth, but it takes a couple more swipes for me. Not as moisture-rich and almost too pink. It has more of a fuchsia look to it. If I had blush and lighter eye shadow, it would work better. Could wear to a happy hour with friends.

2. Inspiration by Smashbox

Inspiration-Sarah.jpg#asset:52382

Inspiration-Molly.jpg#asset:52381

Inspiration-Lydia.jpg#asset:52377

Inspiration-Michelle-2.jpg#asset:53332

Sarah: More satin-like texture with moisturizer feeling. Feels like you could wear in the winter and your mouth wouldn’t shrivel up. I like the shine. No gloss needed! This is a going-out lipstick or a holiday party lipstick. More of a berry tone with glitter-like shine.

Lydia: This is the best texture so far. It’s more pink than I realized it was going to be. I like the plum nature to it, it’s a little bit warmer. Would wear it on a fancy night out.

Molly: Feels smooth and smells like vanilla. Yeah, there does seem to be a sheen. I like the application the best. It’s really festive and fun, probably wear it in the evening. It would look good with a black or neutral outfit.

Michelle: Effortless application—like putting on ChapStick. It’s versatile so I could make it sheer or darker if I wanted to. This is definitely not a daytime color. I love the hot pink color and the sheen on it. Perfect color for date night. Her favorite!

3. King by Lipstick Queen

King-Sarah.jpg#asset:52639

King-Molly.jpg#asset:52637

King-Lydia.jpg#asset:52622

King-Michelle-2.jpg#asset:53333

Sarah: Nice point on the applicator. Texture is good and creamy. This is pushing the edge of how dark a color I can wear. Because it has red and blue, it’s better than something brown and dark. Would maybe want lip liner because it’s so dark.

Lydia: Smooth application. It’s heavily pigmented so you don’t need to use a lot. This one is deeper, more purple. I think it compliments the olive colors of my skin. But it feels like my lips might be drying beneath it.

Molly: This goes on really easy and smooth, but you might need a lip liner because it didn’t go well over my cupid’s bow. I like the color because it’s not so pink. Berry colors look good with my skin, and brings out the golden tones. Would be a fun party shade. Her favorite!

Michelle: I like the applicator point on this one. It’s a little velvety. The precision point helps even if you don’t have a lip liner. Closer to a color I would typically wear. If it had more blue in it and was a little darker, I would love it.

4. Adoring by The Balm Cosmetics

Adoring-Sarah.jpg#asset:52831

Adoring-Molly.jpg#asset:52828

Adoring-Lydia.jpg#asset:52826

Adoring-Michelle-2.jpg#asset:53330

Sarah: Smells like a thin mint and tingles a little bit. Don’t like these kind of applicators—I have to clean up as I go. Really need a liner with these. Like I said, dark stuff goes very quickly from cute to vampire. This does not work for me.

Lydia: The smell reminds me of LipSmackers and the application is like a slip and slide. This is the best, color-wise. The brick-red and brown undertones really work well with my skin. Would wear this out, especially in winter. Her favorite!

Molly: It’s messy and it just wants to not go in a straight line. It globs at the top, so you have to scrape off the excess. Takes several layers of application. It’s a bold lip, but it goes well with my skin tone. It has more purple undertones so it compliments a redhead.

Michelle: Cookie overload when you smell it! You really need a steady hand to put this on. I do like the brick-red color. Looks better with people who have fuller lips. It’s hard to get an even coat—and stays a little sticky. But it does last a while and won't come off on a wine glass.




Meet The Author

Michelle Harris is the digital content producer for Baltimore, where she covers news, community, sports, and beauty.



You May Also Like


Charmed Life

Style File: Bottle of Bread in Mt. Vernon

Morissa Rothman-Pierce has a new vision for vintage.

Style & Shopping

Direct Message

Local company Mess in a Bottle uses T-shirts to send empowering messages.

Food & Drink

The Newcomer's Guide

How to eat, drink, play, and live like a local.


Arts District

Devlon Waddell Discusses Furniture Company Knot You Vintage

The local artist and storyteller talks creativity and black entrepreneurship.

Health & Wellness

My Top Ten With Priya Narasimhan

The owner of wellness company Priya Means Love shares her favorite things.

Style & Shopping

My Top Ten With Violet Apple

The CEO of Girls Scouts of Central Maryland shares her favorite things.

Connect With Us

Most Read


Open & Shut: The Local Fry; The Hoof Cafe; Monument City Brewing: The latest openings, closings, and recent news.

TLC, Toots and The Maytals, and ZZ Ward to Headline Artscape 2018: This year's theme-less free arts festival lets local and national art shine.

Merritt Clubs Participates in the World’s Largest Swim Lesson: On June 21, these Baltimore-area gyms will teach water safety to 500 people.

Lou Catelli is Serious About Running for Mayor of Baltimore in 2020: The unofficial mayor of Hampden wants to be the official mayor of Baltimore.

Salvation Army Booth House Shelter in Mt. Vernon to Close on July 2: Due to lack of federal funding, the temporary housing program will shutter after 80 years.