Review: Beatriz at Dinner

Dinner party from hell makes you squirm—and makes you think.

By Max Weiss | June 25, 2017, 9:34 pm

-Roadside Attractions

Review: Beatriz at Dinner

Dinner party from hell makes you squirm—and makes you think.

By Max Weiss | June 25, 2017, 9:34 pm

-Roadside Attractions

Get Baltimore Daily.

Sign up today and you'll get our latest stories delivered straight to your inbox every weekday afternoon.

How are we supposed to feel about Beatriz (Salma Hayek), the protagonist of Miguel Arteta’s Beatriz at Dinner? It’s clear she’s supposed to be a good person—a healer (she does massage for cancer patients), an empath who reads other people and instantly absorbs their thoughts and pain, a lover of all God’s creatures, including her pet goats. But is she also supposed to be . . . annoying and self-righteous?

Since Beatriz at Dinner was written by Mike White, who gave us the deliciously uncomfortable Chuck and Buck, I’ll assume the squirm-factor was baked into the cake. There are some who will undoubtedly see Beatriz as a working class hero. I saw her more as a really bad dinner guest.

The set up: After leaving the cancer center where she works, Beatriz drives to a Los Angeles hills mansion where she gives a massage to longtime client Cathy (Connie Britton), who’s getting ready for a big dinner party. Cathy and her husband Grant (David Warshofsky) are hosting his boss, a big-shot, famous businessman named Doug Strutt (John Lithgow) and his wife (Amy Landecker), as well as an ambitious young colleague (Jay Duplass) and his wife (Chloë Sevigny). But when Beatriz goes to leave, her car won’t start and Cathy asks her to stay for dinner. It’s an ill-advised bit of noblesse oblige. Cathy should know that this dinner party, where everyone will be sucking up to Doug, drinking heavily, and talking shop, would be extremely unwelcoming to any outsider, let alone a modest and earthy Mexican woman.

⇓ Article continues below ⇓

At first, everything goes as we might expect: The guests are merry and vulgar in their confidence, their casual displays of superficiality and wealth, and Beatriz hangs back, feeling sheepish and shy. Inevitably, Doug mistakes her for the help.

But then something unexpected happens—first at dinner, where Beatriz doesn’t yield the floor to Doug, as everyone else has, but tells her own story of a fishing trip with her father. Later, she finds out that Doug is a big game hunter and she throws a phone at him. After doing some research, she discovers that Doug has made his money by developing preserved wild land and kicking poor people out of their homes. He’s a monster and she loathes him.

Lithgow is particularly great here. It’s easy to say that his Doug is a Donald Trump type, except he’s much more shrewd than that. He’s amused, to a point, by Beatriz’s hatred of him, and he has no guilt, no conscience—he’s already convinced himself that the only reason he’s successful is because he has the balls to get the job done where lesser men do not.

Sporting unflattering short bangs and drab attire, Hayek is wonderful, too—her still, watchful gaze regarding her fellow dinner guests first with keen interest and eventually contempt. She's a wolf in sheep's clothing. That being said, I was a little troubled by the idea it was a Mexican woman who was so full of spiritual energy and healing powers—it felt a bit pandering, an Hispanic take on the dreaded “Magic Negro” archetype. Likewise, the film’s judgment of the wealthy dinner guests felt overly facile and obvious. Yes, the guests are shallow and greedy. But it’s Beatriz who’s violating the social contract, not them. At one point, Cathy essentially sends Beatriz to her room and I felt a sense of relief—hoping she wouldn’t ruin the party any more.

There’s a part of me that admires Beatriz at Dinner. It made me deeply uncomfortable, which not many films can do. It made me question my own reaction to it. I can’t quite say I enjoyed it, but I’m not going to forget it that easily, either.

Meet The Author
Max Weiss is the managing editor of Baltimore and a film and pop culture critic.

You May Also Like


Review: Good Time

In-your-face film is impressive, if exhausting.

Arts & Culture

J. Roddy Talks New Album and Baltimore Music Scene

With a new album and local concerts on the horizon, the rock-and-roll singer reflects on his more formidable days in Baltimore.

Arts & Culture

Writer Madison Smartt Bell Talks About New Book

The author and Goucher professor joins us to talk about his new book Behind the Moon.

Arts & Culture

Music Reviews: September 2017

The latest from J Pope and the HearNow and J. Roddy Walston and the Business.

In Good Taste

Everyman Theatre Brings Back Pre-Show Food and Drink Pairings

Program to highlight Ekiben, Dylan’s Oyster Cellar, Lobo, local breweries, and more.

Arts District

The Big Baltimore Playlist: August 2017

The top five local songs you should download right now.

Connect With Us

Most Read

Head of the Class
Sonja Santelises is ready to lead Baltimore City Public Schools.

The Book Thing Bounces Back
A Baltimore literary institution gets reborn, thanks to the community.

Mug Life
We've gathered some of the most clever mugs to start your day.

The Secret Life of Bees
Local honey is the bee’s knees.

My Top Ten by Rachel Mulherin
The local jewelry designer shares her favorite things.