Sugar Rush

Edited by Suzanne Loudermilk Haughey - February 2014

Our Favorite Cookies

Sugar Rush

Edited by Suzanne Loudermilk Haughey - February 2014

Assorted Italian cookies, Vaccaro's -Photography by Christopher Myers


Several locations including 222 Albemarle St., 410-685-4905.

While the bakery's luscious cannoli with sweet ricotta and milk-chocolate morsels may be its top seller, it also offers an array of outstanding cookies, including pignoli cookies with almond paste and pine nuts, butter sandwich cookies with Nutella and coated with powdered sugar, and a gluten-free croccantini (cocoa powder and almond bites).

Editor's pick: Chocolate biscotti dipped in white chocolate.

Berger Cookies

Found at local stores.

While the bakery plant in Cherry Hill has been passed along to different families through the years, the recipe—a white-cake-like cookie with a layer of chocolate fudge—remains the same, at least, for now. If the FDA approves a ban on trans fat, the texture could change in the future. In the meantime, our hometown favorite can be found in other concoctions like Taharka Brothers's Berger Cookie Ice Cream.

Eddie's of Roland Park

Two locations including 5113 Roland Ave., 410-323-3656.

Eddie's, run by the Cohen family, has long been a go-to grocery for neighborhood types who don't feel like cooking—or baking. The dessert case is filled with cookies in all shapes and sizes, from walnut-filled Russian tea cookies and hazelnut shortbreads to coconut macaroons.

Editor's pick: Sugar cookies in seasonal shapes that taste homemade. Try the pink hearts for Valentine's Day.

Gourmet Again

3713 Old Court Rd., Pikesville, 410-484-9393.

The grocery aggregates cookies from all over the region—from Brooklyn, NY, home of Erica's Rugelach; Gourmet Bakery in Baltimore, which supplies the icebox cookies; and Goldman's Kosher Bakery in Reisterstown, maker of strawberry fingers dipped in chocolate.

Editor's pick: Chocolate moon cookies.

Otterbein's Cookies

Found at local stores.

In 1881, Adam Otterbein, newly arrived from Germany, opened a small bakery in Locust Point. Today, production takes place in Windsor Mill and is run by Adam's great-grandkids. The wafer-thin cookies, packed in the familiar red windowpane paper bag, come in five flavors: sugar, lemon, ginger, oatmeal raisin, and the best-selling chocolate chip.

Editor's pick: Lemon, a great tea cookie.

You May Also Like

In Good Taste

Baltimore Chefs Hold Fundraisers for Australia Bushfire Relief

Two local restaurants will donate proceeds from service this weekend.

In Good Taste

My Favorite Baltimore Bites of 2019

This was the year I craved simple sandwiches, comfort food, and cocktails to wash it all down.

In Good Taste

Cunningham's Chef Jay Rohlfing Shares Details About Restaurant Rebrand

The Towson spot will reopen with a new concept this spring.

In Good Taste

Where to Eat Chinese Food on Christmas Day

Indulge in a very kosher Christmas.

Food & Drink

A Seat at the Welcome Table

James Beard Award-winning author Toni Tipton-Martin talks about her new cookbook and moving to Baltimore.

Food & Drink

From Baltimore, With Love

These Made in Maryland food businesses fill us with pride of product.

Assorted Italian cookies, Vaccaro's -Photography by Christopher Myers

Connect With Us

Most Read

Meet the Ravens’ 25-Year-Old, Number-Crunching Whiz Who Has John Harbaugh’s Ear: Park School alum Daniel Stern helps call the game-changing shots for his hometown team.

Four Key Updates on the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra: Here’s what the BSO has been up to since performances resumed in September.

Gervonta Davis Wins Another World Title Belt, Eyes ‘Big Year’ Ahead: West Baltimore’s own was bruised, but not beaten in longest fight of his pro career.

Maya Rockeymoore Cummings Declares For Late Husband’s Seat: We break down the familiar faces in upcoming special Democratic primary.

Maryland Politicians React to Trump Impeachment: Local leaders reflect and look ahead at Senate trial.