For the First Time Since 1989, The Oscars Won’t Have a Host

Should we care?

By Max Weiss | February 7, 2019, 4:52 pm


For the First Time Since 1989, The Oscars Won’t Have a Host

Should we care?

By Max Weiss | February 7, 2019, 4:52 pm

In 2011, the Oscars made the head-scratching—if undeniably bold—choice to have actors Anne Hathaway and James Franco co-host the award show. Not quite a match made in heaven. In high school terms, Franco is the bright but underachieving kid getting stoned in the parking lot and Anne Hathaway is the student body president who is also the lead in the school play. If they were dating, you’d say, “Huh, I guess opposites really do attract.” Nonetheless, host together they did and the results were memorably awful. They never found a rhythm, Franco seemed bored, Hathaway began to get a little twitchy. There were even some conspiracy theories that Franco had intentionally tanked the hosting gig as part of some performance art project. (He insists he actually tried to do a good job. #NancyPelosiClap)

So the Academy knew exactly what to do the next year—return to the most reliable, well-received, universally beloved host in recent memory: Billy Crystal. A slam dunk, right? Not so fast. Crystal’s performance felt dated, irrelevant, hopelessly out of touch (he did his Sammy Davis Jr. blackface, for God’s sake.) And suddenly, thanks to social media, we were seeing the public’s less than enthusiastic reaction in real time.

That’s the thing about social media—you can’t hide from it. We look back nostalgically at the hosting gigs of Bob Hope, Johnny Carson, and Crystal and think they were the kind of smooth, urbane raconteurs that they just don’t make anymore. But what if social media, with its pack mentality and uncharitable instincts, was around back then? Something tells me they wouldn’t have been received quite as enthusiastically. (Conversely, I think Dave Letterman’s much maligned, “Oprah/Uma” shtick might’ve turned into a great meme.)

Suffice it to say, Billy Crystal isn't the only recent host who didn't nail the gig.

Ellen did fine, in an anodyne way, although she started an obnoxious tradition of letting the unwashed masses rub shoulders with the famous stars. (The little people! They’re nothing like us!)

The multi-hyphenate Neil Patrick Harris seemed like he would be a perfect host, but he got off to a rough start and never recovered, getting increasingly desperate as the show went on (remember the lockbox?)

Seth MacFarlane brought his frat-house style of humor to the proceedings, with predictably stupid results. (“I Saw Your Boobs”? Really, Seth?).

Jimmy Kimmel continued in Ellen’s tradition of being just fine! (By Oscar hosting standards, “just fine” is a cause for popping champagne corks.)

At this point, everyone knows what a minefield the Oscar hosting gig is so, understandably, very few celebrities are lining up for the job.

(My suggestion? Go with a rising star, not an established one. A rising star has much more to gain than, say, The Rock, who has little to gain and almost everything to lose.)

When the announcement came that Kevin Hart would be this year’s host, it was already on the late side. And then, Hart’s homophobic tweets were unearthed, the diminutive actor/comedian refused to give a full-throated apology, and we were back to the drawing board.

Yesterday it was finally made official: The Oscars would go on without a host.

And here’s the thing: I’m actually okay with this. No, there won’t be an opening monologue filled with hit-or-miss topical humor and GIF-ready celebrity reaction shots. But there will almost undoubtedly be some sort of filmed sketch or musical extravaganza (or both) to kick things off—and then we’ll go directly to the awards. Honestly, after the opening monologue, the host becomes a bit of an afterthought, anyway. And don’t worry, I promise there will be enough pretty people exchanging painfully awkward scripted banter to go around.

Meet The Author

Max Weiss is the editor-in-chief of Baltimore and a film and pop culture critic.

You May Also Like

The Chatter

Baltimore Gets Very Own Walk of Fame

Hampden’s newest attraction is a John Waters Star Walk.

On The Town

Baltimore Pride Events to Keep You Celebrating All Month Long

From rainbow-themed drinks to glow parties, there are plenty of ways to show your pride this June.

Arts & Culture

Book Reviews: June 2019

The latest from Kevin Cowherd and Richie Frieman.

Arts & Culture

Music Reviews: June 2019

The latest from Abdu Ali and Kotic Couture.

On The Town

Fourth of July Events to Spark Your Interest

Fill your Fourth of July with food, festivities, and—of course—fireworks.

Arts District

The Big Baltimore Playlist: May 2019

The top five local songs you should download right now.

Connect With Us

Most Read

What Pennsylvania Avenue’s Official Arts District Designation Means for the Community: The black arts and entertainment district brings tax incentives and the potential for further revitalization.

A Month Before Woodstock, Led Zeppelin and The Guess Who Rocked the Laurel Pop Festival: Fifty years ago, music’s biggest names shared a stage in Laurel.

Baltimoreans Recount the Moon Landing on Its 50th Anniversary: For those around to see it, the Apollo 11 mission was an especially momentous occasion.

Baltimore-Invented TV Camera Sent Moon Walk Images Around the World: Westinghouse engineer Stanley Lebar built the Apollo 11 lunar television camera.

Charm City Games Kicks Off Inaugural Year at Canton Waterfront Park: Rec and Parks-led initiative hopes to bring kids together in the name of friendly competition.