News & Community

Investigators From The Keepers Share Updates on Sex Abuse Scandal

In our podcast debut, our guests reveal shocking allegations against Father Joseph Maskell.

By Jess Mayhugh | November 20, 2017, 8:30 am

News & Community

Investigators From The Keepers Share Updates on Sex Abuse Scandal

In our podcast debut, our guests reveal shocking allegations against Father Joseph Maskell.

By Jess Mayhugh | November 20, 2017, 8:30 am

—Artwork by Aaron Hope

In our first episode of the Baltimore Boomerang podcast, we revisit an article from December 1995 written by Paul Mandelbaum, which delved into the possible connections between a sex abuse scandal at Archbishop Keough High School in the 1960s and '70s and the 1969 disappearance and murder of a nun Sister Cathy Cesnik. The majority of the allegations center around Father Joseph Maskell, the school's chaplain at the time.

Our guests included investigators Alan Horn and Abbie Schaub (a Keough alumn who had Cesnik as her English teacher), as well as Teresa Lancaster, who testified in the mid-90s that Maskell sexually abused her while she was a student at Keough. On the episode, our guests revealed shocking allegations against Maskell, possible leads into Cesnik's murder, and came forward with new information that has come to light since their story was told in the Netflix documentary The Keepers. We also shared a statement from the Archdiocese of Baltimore in response to the myriad allegations.

After the episode recording, we reached out to our guests for follow-up questions, specifically regarding the closure of Seton Keough (formerly Archbishop Keough) in Southwest Baltimore. "I can't speak for all of my classmates," Schaub said. "But the only sentiments I've heard were from other old friends who share my sense of relief that no more young women will walk those tainted halls."

Lancaster, who was known as Jane Roe during the investigation into Maskell's abuse, shares a similar sentiment about the closing of her alma mater.

"My mom was so very proud to send me to Keough, a safe place for her only daughter to blossom into an independent woman," she said. "But I am very happy Keough was closed. This action helped me in my continuing efforts to put the horror I suffered at Keough behind me.  People need to know these things are very real and continue to happen today."

Meet The Author
Jess Mayhugh is the digital editor for Baltimore, where she covers nightlife, sports, food, and events.

Baltimore Business Directories

The Latest

The Chatter

Sessions Comes to City Pledging To Speed Deportations

AG also says FBI likely to assume investigation into police officer’s death.

The Chatter

A Shipment of Domino Sugar Heads to the International Space Station

The Baltimore-based product was launched into space as part of an experiment.

In Good Taste

Best Bites of 2017

From rockfish and grits to a green chile cheeseburger, here are our favorite dishes of the year.

On The Town

Ring in 2018 With These New Year’s Eve Parties and Concerts

From family fun to midnight music, here’s your New Year’s Eve going-out guide.

Arts District

Blind Balloon Artist HongSeok Goh Shows Off Massive Work at AVAM

South Korea artist creates one-of-a-kind installation at the American Visionary Art Museum.

In Good Taste

Best Fireplaces in Town

Put a little fire in your belly at these charming hotspots.

News & Community

One Is Too Many

Looking Baltimore's gun violence epidemic in the eye, one grieving mother at a time.

On The Town

Weekend Lineup: Dec. 8-10

The best things to do in Baltimore this weekend.

Ravens Watch

Justin Tucker Talks Ravens Touchdown Celebrations and Playoff Hopes

The kicker says the team is "really special" and peaking at the right time.


Review: Wonder Wheel

Woody Allen pays homage to the great American plays of the 1950s.

Food & Drink

Sinful Sandwiches

The creations at Ravage Deli are the best thing since sliced bread.

In Good Taste

Open & Shut: Cross Street Market; OpenTable Top 100 List; Hotel Revival

The latest restaurant openings, closings, and recent news.

The Chatter

A Citywide Day of Service to Replace MLK Day Parade

Residents are encouraged to volunteer to celebrate the holiday.

Connect With Us

Most Read

The Most Festive, Family-Friendly Holiday Events : From bright lights to dancing sugar plum fairies, enjoy these kid-friendly happenings.

Bloomberg Donates $5 Million to Baltimore Police To Combat Violence: The BPD will receive new technology including additional cameras, license plate readers, and gunshot detection software.

RavenBeer Moves From Peabody Heights to DuClaw Brewing in Rosedale: Owner Stephen Demczuk says relocations is "good business move."

Meghan Markle Follows Baltimore's Wallis Simpson and Elizabeth Bonaparte into European Royalty: Simpson married King Edward VIII in 1936 while Bonaparte married Napoleon's brother in 1803.

Culture Club: Woke at City Hall, John Waters Christmas, and Grammy Noms: Our monthly roundup of openings, events, and news from the art world.