25 Best Bars: Old Gems

Old gems and new favorites. Plus the 10 top craft-beer havens & where bartenders like to drink.

By Jess Blumberg, Jim Burger, Rebecca Kirkman, Amy Mulvihill, Christine Stutz, & Mike Unger. Photography by Ryan Lavine. - December 2012

25 Best Bars: Old Gems

Old gems and new favorites. Plus the 10 top craft-beer havens & where bartenders like to drink.

By Jess Blumberg, Jim Burger, Rebecca Kirkman, Amy Mulvihill, Christine Stutz, & Mike Unger. Photography by Ryan Lavine. - December 2012

An Poitin Stil

By 7:15 p.m., An Poitin Stil’s parking lot is filled. Inside, happy hour is bleeding into a bender. Four small groups of officemates are spread throughout The Stil, that rarest of breed, a county establishment that feels more bar than restaurant. Not that it lacks tasty fare. The Stil offers Irish classics like fish and chips and stew. Behind the eight-sided main bar, conversation varies from shop talk to gossip as the Harps flow. Outside on the heated “paddy ’o,” more white collars lean on the semi-circular bar, sipping suds while a duo plays familiar classic rock tunes. It’s 9 p.m. now, and comments like, “You want a Jäger bomb?” and “What’s your favorite kind of underwear?” are overheard. Tomorrow should be an interesting workday, assuming everyone makes it into the office. 2323 York Road, 410-560-7900, thestill.net

The Brewer’s Art

Mt. Vernon
Walk up to The Brewer’s Art, and you’re faced with a decision. Head through the double doors into the foyer of the grand row house-turned-restaurant or descend the stairs to the dim and grimy wine cellar-turned-bar. You’ll be happy either way—the upstairs exudes elegance, with dark wood molding and marble fireplaces. When you feel like late-night drinks, downstairs is the perfect hangout with its cozy corner tables carved with initials. But what we have to mention is the beer. Six tap handles, some handmade by brewers, signal what’s on draft for the night: a roughly hewn cross for their famous abbey brown ale Resurrection, a hand throwing up metal horns for their devilish, Belgian-style Ozzy (a signed, black-and-white image of the star himself sits behind the bar), and so on. All suds are brewed on-site, but if beer’s not your thing (we’ll let it slide), extensive wine and whiskey lists are sure to quench your thirst. 1106 N. Charles Street, 410-547-9310, thebrewersart.com

Cat’s Eye Pub

Fells Point
Venture into Cat’s Eye Pub, and you’ll be welcomed with open arms—or at least a handshake across the bar from co-owner Tony Cushing Jr. A family-owned Baltimore staple for more than 35 years, the bar has a steady group of regulars and tourists on pilgrimage. (It made All About Beer’s list of 125 places to have a beer before you die.) The dive’s eclectic décor has influences Irish, maritime, and downright random. (An upside-down Christmas tree hangs from the ceiling.) Talented bands and a come-as-you-are vibe distinguish this pub from its neighbors. There’s live music every night (one particularly awesome blues band improvised lyrics about an O’s game) and the front bar is crowded with dancers. Move to the back room or patio for laid-back conversation with a crowd diverse in age and style. You’ll find no pretense here, just genuine people looking to have a good time. 1730 Thames Street, 410-276-9866, catseyepub.com

The Club Charles

Station North
Whatever you might have heard about The Club Charles, it’s probably true. Yes, it can be cliquish and dripping with hipster attitude—what do you want? Matt Porterfield hangs out here!—but it also has low drink prices and very competent bartenders. The music alone could keep you there for hours, crafting your own playlist that includes the Cocteau Twins, James Brown, The Velvet Underground, and The Jesus Lizard. The place is really, really red, but that only adds to the den-of-iniquity vibe. It’s got two bars and several retro-looking booths and cubbies. The kitchen next door pumps out tasty burgers and pizza, and if you’re drinking on a budget, it’s hard to beat $2.75 for a PBR and $4.30 for a pint of Guinness. Sure, The Club Charles is not the easiest place to make new friends, but that shouldn’t matter since you’ll probably run into someone you know. 1724 N. Charles Street, 410-727-8815, theclubcharles.com

Curb Shoppe Bar & Grill

Mt. Washington
Everything’s in such tight proximity at the Curb Shoppe that the cops on one side of the bar can almost certainly hear the conversation about drugs that two men and a woman are having on the other. (It doesn’t help that these three appear to have been on their stools for quite some time, and as such, they’re pretty much shouting.) Neither group cares. It’s comfort not conflict that has kept the Curb Shoppe around all these years. It serves sandwiches on white, wheat, or rye—a practice, like the place itself, that’s seems timeless. If you’re not craving a plate of the Curb Shoppe’s classic burger bites or gravy fries—not likely—help yourself to a basket of pretzels on the bar. The beer is cold, the drinks are strong, and maybe the only proof that it’s 2012 and not 1982 is the constant parade of people walking outside to smoke. 5736 Falls Road, 410-433-8299, curbshoppe.com

Duda’s Tavern

Fells Point
Duda’s has come a long way from its mid-century origins as a shot-and-beer bar, a gathering place—and occasional boarding house—for ship captains and seafaring men. Now operated by the third generation of the Duda family, the attractively renovated tavern, at the corner of Bond and Thames, is a comfortable spot to enjoy a Resurrection draft, some complimentary peanuts, and a really delicious crab cake on a soft brioche roll. Weeknight and happy-hour specials provide more reasons to visit Duda’s and enjoy the ’80s music, pleasing draft selection, and sports shown on three TVs. In warm weather, the crowd spills onto the sidewalk, where a handful of tables offer a cafe feel. 1600 Thames Street, 410-276-9719, dudastavern.com

Frazier’s on the Avenue

After pouring a glass of red wine, filled to the brim, our bartender asks us not for cash or a credit card, but for our names. We’re at the smaller of Frazier’s two bars (the one in the room with a single pool table) and, even though we’re the only people here he doesn’t know, he treats us like we’re regulars. We will be soon. The sum of its nuances makes Frazier’s special—the flavorful salsa served with the potato skins, the wide wooden bar with a step on which to rest your feet and a ledge for your elbows, and the welcoming people on both sides of it. After splitting two salmon cakes and a delicious plate of fries, we order a nightcap. Our driver asks if she can get a half glass of wine. “Sure,” the bartender says. You get the feeling that he rarely says “no.” He starts pouring, looks up smiling, and says, “Just say when.” 919 W. 36th Street, 410-662-4914

Howard’s Subway

In July of 1946, Oscar Howard Sensibaugh and his wife, Ruby, bought a house on Hammonds Ferry Road and opened a bar in the basement. The underground location begat its enigmatic name: Subway. Four generations of Sensibaughs have worked the bar since, and honor Howard’s creation. It is a monument to what a basement bar should look like—a precise mixture of Formica, wood paneling, tile and terrazzo floors, red-leather stools, and amber wall sconces. Judy the bartender scolds a customer for using profanity, and he sheepishly apologizes. At a corner booth, five young men share a pitcher of beer. The double doors to the kitchen swing open and Karen Sensibaugh carries a tray of loudly sizzling New York strip steaks. As she runs to the table, smoke trails behind her, and when she sets the metal platters down, the men applaud and cheer. As they eat, a mouthwatering aroma fills the room, and several patrons ask to see menus. 711 N. Hammonds Ferry Road, 410-789-6609

Jennings Cafe

Jennings Cafe feels a lot like your uncle’s knotty-pine clubroom, and even the regulars will welcome you like a long-lost cousin. Family-owned-and-operated since 1958, Jennings is a comfortable spot to have a few beers and watch the game with the guys, but it’s wholesome enough to bring the kids for dinner, even complete with a children’s menu that includes spaghetti, hot dogs, and chicken tenders—plus, plenty of choices for grownups. Try the popular crab cakes, soft crabs, and shrimp salad with a side of cucumber and onions, lovingly prepared by the matriarch herself, Mrs. Jennings. With a subtle horse-racing theme referencing its roots, and waitresses who just might pull up a chair and shoot the breeze while you eat, Jennings has a comfortably dated feel. The only modern element might be the clever addition of Fat Tire ale to the tap array. 808 Frederick Road, 410-744-3824, jenningscafe.com

Johnny Dee’s Lounge

Tucked in the lower level of the Loch Ridge Shopping Center, Johnny Dee’s Lounge is literally a hideaway. Walk through the unassuming doors and be transported to another time. This isn’t your grandfather’s lounge, unless your grandfather was very hip. The main room is filled with enough vintage mid-century modern furniture to make the set designers of Mad Men weep. If you don’t want to sit in the lounge, try to get a seat at the bar. Its “L” shape, with nine black leather stools crowded around it, makes it ideal for chatting up strangers or drinking with a friend. If you want a beer, go ahead and order one of the 20 bottled brands in stock. But there’s something about the place that just makes you want a cocktail—a classic martini, Manhattan, or Tom Collins. Bartenders Joan, Tiffany, and Henry pour 30 years of combined experience into every drink. Small plaques bearing the names of good customers line the walls—they can’t be purchased, they must be earned. And there’s no better time to start. 1705 Amuskai Road, 410-665-7000

The Judge’s Bench Pub

Ellicott City
In a city where our favorite bars are around the corner, driving 20 minutes down the road seems unnecessary. That is, until we visit The Judge’s Bench Pub in Ellicott City. Located right on quaint Main Street, the stone building bedazzled with white Christmas lights gives off an immediately warm feeling. We plop down on two open bar stools and notice a diverse array of beer taps hanging from the ceiling and marvel at how the bartender, Carrie, seems to know everyone’s back story. “How’s the new job?” she’ll ask. “Did you get a haircut?” Though we’re not regulars, she’s sweet as can be as we order a beer flight (four 4-ounce pours) including Ommegang Abbey, Heavy Seas Great Pumpkin, Stoudts Achluophobia, and a Weyerbacher Heresy stout. Without missing a beat, she assures us that the Stoudts isn’t too strong, and only clocks in at 4.8 percent ABV. Rumors are this place is haunted (like most of Ellicott City), but we can’t help but feel a sense of total comfort, and we’re not the only ones. “That’s what happens,” says a middle-aged man next to us. “You come in here for one drink and, before you know it, they’re closing down.” 8385 Main Street, 410-465-3497, judgesbenchpub.com


Mt. Vernon
No one seems to remember the name of the first bar at the corner of Tyson Street and Park Avenue, or how long it had been there. But in 1957 it was called Leon’s, and Leon’s was the first “gay-friendly” bar in Baltimore. So, to Charm City’s gay community, it’s hallowed ground. On Sunday nights, the place is packed and fun. Patrons, all male, are spilling out the front door onto the sidewalk. Inside, Ben the bartender works the oval bar, quickly serving two-for-one, happy-hour drinks. It’s a dark, low-ceilinged place, and techno music blares from the speakers without overwhelming the conversations. There is no uniform: Denim is as prevalent as leather; Orioles and Ravens jerseys are both represented; and men in Polo shirts sit next to men wearing no shirts at all. Hugs and kisses get exchanged when walking in, even if you walked out just a minute before. Some patrons are obviously alone, but no one looks lonely. And maybe that’s all anyone should ask of any bar, gay or straight. 870 Park Avenue, 410-539-4993, leonsbaltimore.tripod.com

Muir’s Tavern

South Baltimore
There was a time when Fort Avenue was lined with family-owned bars—perhaps as many as 30 between Race Street and Fort McHenry. South Baltimore’s locals bought drinks from their neighbors in places called Cox’s, Hartlove’s, and Henry’s. Today those names are nothing but memories, only Muir’s remains. It’s a Formstone castle at the corner of Marshall Street and Fort Avenue with a classic Baltimore pedigree. It was founded in 1944 by Roland Muir, a tugboat captain, who ran the place and lived upstairs. His son, Roland Jr. took over in 1968, but not before he worked 23 years as a longshoreman and 18 years for the National Brewing Company. Inside, it’s pure Baltimore: There’s a framed portrait of Johnny Unitas on the wall, the Natty Boh signage dates back to when it was actually made here, and red neon light bathes everything. The bar fills up on a Friday afternoon and Roland Jr. sits at a back table with his nephew, Tom, the third-generation Muir at the helm. They clink two beer cans together and toast the approach of the seventh decade. 36 E. Fort Avenue, 410-385-0344

You May Also Like

Food & Drink

Local Flavor Live Podcast: Knowing Where Your Chocolate Comes From

Jinji Fraser of Pure Chocolate by Jinji joins us to talk about the ancestral qualities of cacao.

Food & Drink

Local Flavor Live Podcast: The Thrill of Foraging

Chef Chris Amendola talks indoor dining reclosures and foraging tips for beginners.

Food & Drink

Three Sips That Evoke The Spirit of Summer

Wine and spirits to look out for at your favorite bottle shop.

In Good Taste

Celebrate Orioles Opening Day with These Carryout Specials

From ice cream to bagels, here are orange-inspired eats to enjoy from home.

In Good Taste

Without Reservation: Tark’s Grill

Co-owner Gino Cardinale discusses the restaurant’s survival and memories of his beloved City Café.

In Good Taste

This Summer’s Restaurant Week Lineup is More Inclusive Than Ever

Promotion expands to coffee shops and fast-casual eateries in the wake of COVID-19.

Connect With Us

Most Read

How These Surprise Quarantine ‘Flower Bombs’ Are Helping Families in Need: The paper-plate flowers have become a massive fundraiser for the Ronald McDonald House.

The Womanist Reader Creates an Online Library of Black Literature: A Baltimore writer curates an evolving list of women writers for her women followers.

Amid The Economic Chaos, Downtown Partnership’s New President Has a Plan: Shelonda Stokes was just named president after serving in an interim leadership role.

How the Orioles Are Preparing for a “Pandemic Season”: Staying apart is the new team bonding experience.

Design for Distancing Competition Aims to Revive The Beauty of Public Spaces: Forward-thinking social-distancing structures could be built in the city as early as this month.