MaxSpace

Movie Review: Three Identical Strangers

Astonishing documentary tells the stranger-than-fiction story of triplets who were separated at birth.

By Max Weiss | August 6, 2018, 5:32 pm

-Neon Films
MaxSpace

Movie Review: Three Identical Strangers

Astonishing documentary tells the stranger-than-fiction story of triplets who were separated at birth.

By Max Weiss | August 6, 2018, 5:32 pm

-Neon Films

The beauty of Tim Wardle’s Three Identical Strangers is this: It not only has a wildly improbable and fascinating story to tell, it has wonderful characters to tell it.

Here’s the story: An adopted young man named Robert Shafran turns up the first day of college and is greeted like an old friend—slaps on the back from the boys, kisses from the girls—by complete strangers. Shafran thinks he must have a lookalike, but it’s much more than that: He has a twin, Eddie Galland, from whom he was separated at birth. The two boys meet and have their incredible story chronicled by the local newspaper. It’s at that point that a friend of another 19-year-old boy—David Kellman—sees the photo and freaks out. You guessed it. These boys aren’t just twins, they’re triplets.

The three boys—all of whom were raised by Jewish families in the suburbs of New York City—meet and are instantly inseparable. They marvel at their similarities, in not just appearance, but mannerisms, hobbies (all three were high school wrestlers), and taste in food and women. Suddenly, they’re all over TV and the newspapers: The Today Show, The Phil Donahue Show, People magazine. It was 1980 in New York and the boys—who were all handsome with mops of curly dark hair and infectious, toothy grins—became the toast of the town, getting red rope treatment at nightclubs like Studio 54 and The Limelight. They were loving the ride, but their adopted parents—none of whom had been informed that they were breaking up infant brothers—demanded answers. From there, the film goes down some deeply disturbing paths as it explores nature vs. nurture, separation anxiety, the legacy of mental illness, and ethics in psychiatry.

Now, about those characters. Two of the three brothers—Robert and David—now in their late 50s, are interviewed in the film and they are wonderful storytellers: funny, garrulous, emotionally accessible, and blessed with apparently great memories. The filmmakers also have a veritable treasure trove of documentary footage and photos to share, considering that the boys became minor celebs. As the film goes on—and explores more of what happened to the boys and why they were separated—it gets darker and darker. But the film’s greatest strength—that it’s a helluva yarn—is also its biggest weakness. Wardle sacrifices some of the film’s more intriguing and thornier themes in favor of a compelling, shocking narrative. I also had a bit of a problem with the highly subjective nature of his lens. Film, as you know, can be a sneakily persuasive medium. The way characters are filmed and how they are edited affects our perception of them—and I felt that Wardle indicted some of the characters a little irresponsibly. (One interview subject is filmed at grotesque angles; another one is essentially blamed for a tragic event through narrative juxtaposition.)

The less you know about Three Identical Strangers going in the better. It’s utterly captivating—an OMG story that truly has to be seen to be believed—but I do wish it had dug just a bit deeper.


Three Identical Strangers is now playing the Senator Theatre




Meet The Author

Max Weiss is the editor-in-chief of Baltimore and a film and pop culture critic.



You May Also Like


Arts District

We Take You Inside the 30th Annual Open Studio Tour

From warehouse spaces to lounge areas, the studios reveal private world of each artist.

Arts & Culture

Cameo: Katie Marquette

We talk with the host and producer of The Noir and Bizarre podcast.

On The Town

Can’t-Miss Attractions at the Maryland State Fair

Check out these eats, exhibits, and events at the annual fair returning this weekend.


Arts & Culture

Cult Classic

John Waters shares highlights from his upcoming Baltimore Museum of Art retrospective.

Arts District

Florence and the Machine to Headline Anthem in D.C. This Weekend

Local musicians weigh in on how the band has influenced them over the years.

Arts District

Culture Club: A WTMD Block Party, Hank Willis Thomas at MICA, and Evil Dead: The Musical

Our monthly roundup of openings, events, and news from the art world.

Connect With Us

Most Read


Get an Inside Look at City Architecture with Doors Open Baltimore: The fifth annual event shows off 60 unique buildings and neighborhoods.

Baltimore Musician Hunter Hooligan Debuts Song at New York Fashion Week: "Pink" served as the soundtrack to designer Stevie Boi's rose-tinted vision.

Ben Jealous Fared Well in Debate, But Will It Make a Difference?: Democratic challenger scores some points, but Gov. Larry Hogan holds a big leads in polls.

Actor Željko Ivanek Hosts 35th Anniversary NAMI Event: The Emmy Award-winner makes his first extended stay in Baltimore since leaving Homicide: Life on the Street.

Baltimore Japan Art Festival Returns to Station North With Illustrator Yusuke Nakamura: The two-day fest will also feature a film series and a family-friendly lineup of outdoor events.