Ice Cream

Sugar Rush

Edited by Suzanne Loudermilk Haughey - February 2014

Our Favorite Ice Cream

Sugar Rush

Edited by Suzanne Loudermilk Haughey - February 2014

-Shutterstock

The Charmery

801 W. 36th St, 410-814-0493.

“I think of things I like and turn them into ice cream," says co-owner David Alima, referring to the store's variety of flavors. Look for winter concoctions like Champagne and strawberry for Valentine's Day and snowmaggedon with snowcap candies—whether or not the weather warrants it.

Editor's pick: Spro coffee, made in collaboration with the Hampden coffee shop down the street.

Maggie Moo's

Several locations including 821 S. Broadway, 410-342-8399.

It's hard to resist endlessly combining the shop's 56 flavors (like banana rum and chocolate Swiss) and 31 mix-ins (including chocolate-covered pretzels and coconut). Other whimsical cold desserts include ice-cream-filled cupcakes and an ice-cream pizza.

Editor's pick: Strawberry Skateboard—strawberry ice cream with rainbow sprinkles and gummy bears.

Pitango Gelato

Several locations including 802 S. Broadway, 410-236-0741.

When Noah Dan moved to the U.S., he missed the gelato of his youth in Italy. He eventually sold his software company and satisfied his longing by opening Pitango in 2006. The creamy, milk-based treat is made on an organic dairy farm in Pennsylvania, each kind built from scratch without chemicals or flavor concentrates.

Editor's pick: The sweet-and-savory black sesame.

Prigel Family Creamery

4852 Long Green Rd., Glen Arm, 410- 510-7488.

The on-site shop, adjacent to the creamery operations and the family's dairy farm, sells ice cream as well as milk, meat, and yogurt. The slow-churned ice cream includes flavors like Bobby's black mud (chocolate with cappuccino chips) and apple strudel. Order it scooped into a cone, in a sundae with syrup, or packed into a container to take home.

Editor's pick: Caramel pretzel.

Taharka Bros

Available at local stores and restaurants.

Taharka's small factory in Clipper Mill cranks out inventive flavors like “A Dream Preferred" (toasted-coconut ice cream with rum swirl and chocolate Pop Rocks), named after a Langston Hughes poem, and “Pryor Knowledge" with Nutella, nutmeg, nuts, and Nutter Butter cookies. Look for an ice-cream truck in the spring.

Editor's pick: Vanilla, made with ingredients grown on a small farm in Haiti.

Calories in the Cone

Sugar Cone: 40 calories in a single cone

Cake Cone: 17 calories in a single cone





You May Also Like


Food & Drink

Review: Keystone Korner

Harbor East's new jazz and supper club, Keystone Korner, strikes the right note.

In Good Taste

Local Bread Subscriptions Are Making Fresh Loaves More Accessible Than Ever

These pre-paid methods are the best thing on the market since, well, sliced bread.



Food & Drink

Local Flavor Live Podcast: A Critic's Guide to Going Out to Eat

Plus upcoming Baltimore favorites launch pop-ups, our sources for food inspiration, and best bites of the week.

Food & Drink

Review: Noona's

Noona’s keeps it casual in Bolton Hill.


-Shutterstock

Connect With Us

Most Read


What the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra’s One-Year Agreement Means For its Musicians: After a tension-filled absence, the BSO’s 104th season will open this weekend.

History of Baltimore's Bygone Synagogues Captured in New Plein Air Art Exhibit: Collection of oil paintings on view at Baltimore Hebrew Congregation through October 28.

A New Production of 'The Phantom of the Opera' Is Headed to the Hippodrome: Go behind the mask with the tour's Phantom, Derrick Davis.

New City Council Bill Could Ban Plastic Bag Use Across Baltimore: A vote next week could set in motion a bill that reaches the mayor’s desk.

The Orioles Aren’t Moving Out of Town, But They Have a Long Way To Go: Putting a wrap on relocation rumors and the O’s predictable 2019 season.