The Chatter

Demolition of Baltimore City Detention Center Sparks Intense Debate

Demolition contract would see historic site razed and rehabilitation center installed in its place.

By Evan Greenberg | July 10, 2019, 1:33 pm

The Chatter

Demolition of Baltimore City Detention Center Sparks Intense Debate

Demolition contract would see historic site razed and rehabilitation center installed in its place.

By Evan Greenberg | July 10, 2019, 1:33 pm

A few weeks ago, a friend texted Baltimore activist Kelly Cross a photo of an advertisement for the shuttered Eastern State Penitentiary in Philadelphia, urging people to come visit what has since been turned into a tourist attraction. The irony, as Cross notes, is that the ad in question is about six blocks away from the Baltimore City Detention Center, located off Interstate 83 in the Mount Vernon area.

Recently, plans were announced surrounding its demolition, along with a proposed subsequent substance abuse and mental health rehabilitation center for inmates in its place. Cross and other critics of the move see a grander vision for what could be done with the space—a Philadelphia-like model, for instance.

“It seems a lot of times Baltimoreans are just somehow willing to allow things to happen that should not or would not happen in other cities,” Cross says. “Nowadays you don’t put a massive correctional facility smack dab in the middle of your town.”

It’s important to note that those who might criticize this decision take issue with the location in which it’s happening, and not necessarily the practice itself. Before it was closed, the Baltimore City Detention Center held inmates serving short sentences and those awaiting trial. It’s a building that dates back to the Civil War, and there is a historical preservation angle that objectors feel is being ignored. Cross sees ways to capitalize on the city’s history and turn a jail with a less-than-storied history into a net positive.

“It’s a massive lost opportunity,” Cross says. “There are plenty of other places in the city that don’t have the same strategic and economic value to the viability of Baltimore where you can have those activities. There are facilities where these people can be held and these services can be administered. That’s a laudable goal and we can find plenty of places to do that, but taking demolishing irreplaceable history to make that happen—that’s where I start scratching my head.”

The other side of this, of course, is what is going to be done with the space. While there is dissent, there is not much contention with the idea of doing what is best for prisoners.

“One of the real tragedies of our system, when it gets overcrowded, is that the vast majority of people that were in this detention center were awaiting trial,” says Dr. Gary LaFree, professor and chair of the University of Maryland’s Criminology & Criminal Justice Department. “They hadn’t been convicted yet. If ever there were a group of people that you would want to isolate from the worst problems of prison it would be this group. Particularly for this population, an emphasis on rehabilitation or humane treatment is especially important.”

LaFree acknowledges Cross’ side of the argument, that yes, perhaps there are better uses for a specific facility than another prison or rehabilitation center. “Obviously it’s not as positive as a recreation center or a library,” he says. “Prisons are not the whole solution to [crime problems in Baltimore], but I think they might be regarded as part of the solution.”

Another side to this debate are the questions surrounding building another center at all. Prisons are expensive to maintain and run, and building another one brings about reservations regarding utility and whether a reconstruction on this site is a viable solution.

“It’s a situation where I think the best evidence suggests that prisons do have an impact on reducing crime, but they come at a pretty high cost,” LaFree says. There is some evidence that our incarceration rates have been falling and we’re not seeing a rise in crime.”

Ultimately, nothing has been done yet, and while plans have been announced, Cross is hopeful that he might be able to appeal to the powers that be and get those in charge to see things his way.

“There are lots of places to help prisoners,” Cross says. “It’s not like we’re some landlocked city where we don’t have plenty of available land to help prisoners. I think it’s about taking the path of least resistance.”

Meet The Author

Evan Greenberg is the digital editorial assistant for Baltimore magazine. A native of Atlanta, he works on digital initiatives and explores the how and why of what makes the people, places, and things of Baltimore tick.

You May Also Like

Arts District

Baltimore Museum of Art Debuts New Branch at Lexington Market

BMA partners with the market to provide art programs, presentations, and gatherings.

News & Community

Public Trust

Fifty years in, Maryland Public Television continues to look to the future.

The Chatter

Reopening of Harlem Park Recreation Center Marks a New Beginning

The West Baltimore hub is back, serving as a model for future Rec and Parks projects.

The Chatter

Baltimore City Takes on Trump after President’s Vitriolic Attacks

Donald Trump adds people of Baltimore, Rep. Elijah Cummings, Maryland Congressional District to growing list of black and brown targets.

The Chatter

Charm City Games Kicks Off Inaugural Year at Canton Waterfront Park

Rec and Parks-led initiative hopes to bring kids together in the name of friendly competition.

The Chatter

What You Need to Know for Artscape 2019

A changing footprint, exciting exhibitions, and nods to the moon landing highlight annual festival.

Connect With Us

Most Read

Severe Flooding Plagues Neighborhoods Surrounding the Inner Harbor: Stark images of Harbor East and Fells Point arise on social media as area reckons with heavy rainfall.

Greektown’s Yard 56 Mixed-Use Development to Open by 2020: Project on former Pemco industrial site will be anchored by Streets Market & Cafe and LA Fitness.

What is the Likelihood of President Trump Coming to Baltimore?: With a House Republican conference and an invitation from Elijah Cummings, a presidential visit might be imminent.

Oletha DeVane Showcases Sculptural Works in 'Traces of Spirit' at the BMA: Local multidisciplinary artist explores religion, nature, and humanity in exhibit on view through October 20.