Review: Hungry Andy's

Hungry Andy’s in Fells Point serves pit beef and more.

Suzanne Loudermilk - August 2018

Review: Hungry Andy's

Hungry Andy’s in Fells Point serves pit beef and more.

Suzanne Loudermilk - August 2018


The pit beef sandwich and fries at Hungry Andy's. -Justin Tsucalas

The original Andy has left the building, but caterer Damon Chapman pounced on a chance to take over Hungry Andy’s in Fells Point last year.

You could easily walk past the modest storefront located a few blocks from the main thrum of Thames Street. The luncheonette setting with 18 seats may not have the trendiest décor, but it is spotless and cheery. And the personable staff, including manager and Chapman’s wife, Rashawn, are welcoming.

On the food front, Chapman is putting creative touches on a menu that stars casual American fare such as ribs, burgers, fried chicken, and Baltimore’s quintessential sandwich, pit beef.

Andy’s captures the nuances of the signature meat pileup that is usually sold at roadside stands: meltingly tender beef cooked to order, zippy tiger sauce blending horseradish and mayo, and pungent onions, either raw, sautéed, or both.

Rashawn proudly explains the process: A hunk of top-round beef is crusted with spices and cooked in a smoker for several hours until the interior is a succulent pink. It’s finished in the restaurant char-broiler, where the meat can be prepared to a customer’s preference.

It’s our go-to sandwich. Every time we bite into the pillowy roll and pliable folds of meat, we are reminded of our Baltimore culinary heritage. It’s the same with Hungry Andy’s crab cake. The six-ounce, broiled patty was moister than many, but it is studded with crab lumps. It’s also available in 4-ounce and 9-ounce sizes.

We paired the crab cake with a Caesar salad that may have wowed us more if we had asked for the dressing on the side. The vinaigrette, while silky and pleasantly garlicky, saturated the delicate ribbons of romaine lettuce.

A better side dish is the salty French fries. Chapman says the potatoes are fresh-cut and soaked in water to draw out the starch. The sticks are par-fried and then re-cooked for crispness. The result is a crunchy coating with a soft inside that is addictive.

Hungry Andy’s also offers lunch specials, which recently included a BLT, grilled ham and cheese, and chicken sliders with French fries and a can of soda or bottle of water for $7.30.

Other drinks are self-serve. It’s always difficult to decide between the homemade peach mango iced tea and the homemade lemonade. You won’t go wrong with either—or take Chapman’s advice and mix them for an original half-and-half beverage, a fun take on the Arnold Palmer.

Desserts feature offerings such as chocolate cake and carrot cake. They’re not made in-house, so we suggest heading across the street to Sophia’s Place in the Broadway Market for the classic Polish cookies called chrusciki.

Hungry Andy’s may have lost its namesake founder, but the new proprietor is carving out his own niche—one pit beef sandwich at a time.


›› HUNGRY ANDY'S 629 S. Broadway, 410-558-1869, Mon., Wed., Thurs. 11 a.m.-9 p.m.; Fri. 11 a.m.-11 p.m.; Sat. 11:30 a.m.-11 p.m.; Sun. 11:30 a.m.-9 p.m.





You May Also Like


Food & Drink

A Fresh Start

Greg Nalley founded his fast-casual restaurant chain after a scary bout with cancer.

Food & Drink

All Greek to Us

Without caving to time or trends, Baltimore’s Greektown lives on.

In Good Taste

Open & Shut: Heroes and Helpers in the Food Scene

Spotlighting those working to improve food access and strengthen the service industry.


Food & Drink

Local Flavor Live Podcast: Supporting The Dining Scene While Staying Healthy

We discuss how to invest in your favorite local restaurants amid coronavirus closures.

In Good Taste

Open & Shut: Bmore Licks; Catonsville Gourmet; Gordon Biersch

The latest restaurant openings, closings, and recent news.

On The Town

Three Local Beverages That Celebrate the Women Who Created Them

For Women's History Month, sample local sips made by these female industry leaders.

Connect With Us

Most Read


Baltimore Restaurants Cope With Indefinite Closures: Chefs introduce curbside takeout and delivery while weighing options for staff.

With Emptying Venues, Local Music Community Faces Uncertainty: There are still ways to support local artists during the coronavirus outbreak.

John Waters Flexes Acting Muscles on 'Law & Order: SVU': The Baltimore icon will guest star on an episode of the NBC show later this month.

Maryland Hoops, and Everyone Else, Stomachs A Sudden End to Their Seasons: Plus, an update on Trey Mancini’s health and Joe Flacco shows for Marshal Yanda’s retirement party

Local Boutiques Offer Deals and Online Shopping Amid Coronavirus Outbreak: Opening and closing updates from the retail scene.